In a sign of the global retrenchment of euro area banks, their lending to non-banks in the United States fell further. Euro area banks’ share of total foreign claims on the U.S. non-bank private sector fell to 26 percent at the end of September from a peak of 43 percent in end-June 2007, primarily reflecting lower lending by Dutch and German banks.
New global BIS database shows explosion in total credit
By www.CentralBankNews.info Households worldwide have boosted their borrowing since the 1970s and in some countries, such as the United States and Australia, the total amount now exceeds that of companies, the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) said, introducing a new public database for total credit in 40 countries.
The explosion in household borrowing is one example of what can be gleaned from the BIS’ new global database that fills a glaring void in economists’ understanding of the vital role of credit.
While data on credit in the banking sector has been available, accurate data on credit to the non-financial sector, such as households and corporates, has been largely missing, one of the reasons that policy makers utterly failed to spot the warning signs from the build-up of private sector credit that preceded not only the 2088 financial crises, but most other crises that originate in the financial sector
Up to now, data on lending from foreign lenders and non-banks, such as the unregulated yet massive shadow-banking sector, have also been lacking.
To remedy this, statisticians from Swiss-based BIS – known as the central bankers’ bank – collaborated with 40 central banks from advanced and emerging economies to create a public database that includes total credit from all sources.
The building blocks of the new data series are financial accounts, domestic bank credit and cross-border bank credit.
“The new data cover much longer periods and many more countries than nearly all existing total credit series. On average, 45 years of quarterly data are available. For several countries, including Argentina, Germany, Italy and the United States, data start as early as the late 1940s/early 1950s,” BIS said in its latest quarterly review.
In addition to the growth of household borrowing, the data shows how credit has substantially outgrown economic growth in nearly all countries.
In the 1950s, total credit was around 50 percent of Gross Domestic Product in many advanced economies and then grew over the next 20-30 years and started to top 100 percent in the 1960s and 1970s. By the late 1980s, credit boomed in some countries, such as the United States and the United Kingdom.
Other countries, like Germany and Canada, saw modest credit growth while Ireland is the extreme case: In 1995 it had a credit-to-GDP ratio of around 100 percent. Fifteen years later, the ratio peaked at 317 percent and hasn’t dropped much since.
The explosion of credit with accompanying boom-bust episodes is hardly limited to advanced economies. In Thailand, for example, private sector borrowing rose from 12 percent of GDP in 1958 to 75 percent 30 years later, BIS said.
“A rapid expansion in credit then followed that ended in the 1997 Asian crisis. Thailand’s credit-to-GDP ratio nearly halved over the subsequent 13 years, but started to increase again from 2010 onwards,” BIS said.
In general, emerging economies have tracked advanced economies in increasing the level of household credit. In the 1990s, when data are first collected for emerging economies, household borrowing made up 10-20 percent of total credit. Now, it has risen to 30-60 percent, corresponding to the current levels of many advanced economies.
Fed, BOE QE programs helped dispel deflation fears-BIS
The central banks’ unconventional policies of massive purchases of bonds and other securities – known as quantitative easing – has tripled and quadrupled their balance sheets and triggered fears of inflation and concern over how these programs will be unwound.
In its latest quarterly review, BIS’ Boris Hofman and Feng Zhu analyse the impact on inflation expectations from the BOE and Fed asset purchase programs, from the announcement of the central bank’s plans to their implementation.
As the financial crises spread following the collapse of Lehman Brothers in September 2008, inflation expectations plunged, raising the spectre of deflation. By mid-2009 these fears heightened as consumer prices dropped in both the U.S. and UK.
But the announcement of the asset purchase programs on both sides of the Atlantic in late 2008 and early 2009 lead to a rapid reversal of inflation swap rates towards pre-crises levels in the course of 2009, the authors write.
“This suggests that asset purchase programmes have made an important contribution to fending off deflation risks,” they wrote, adding that other factors, such as stimulus packages and low policy rates may also had an effect that were not captured by their analysis.
Global debt rises but governments fail to reform – BIS
By www.CentralBankNews.info Global debt by households, governments and non-financial enterprises has mushroomed by some $30 trillion since 2007, but governments in advanced economies are not taking advantage of the flood of cheap money to carry out necessary structural reforms that will pay off over time, warned the BIS.
Sharpening the Bank for International Settlement’s (BIS) frequent warnings about the danger of the seemingly endless appetite for debt, its economic adviser, Stephen Cecchetti, said he was concerned because buoyant financial markets have become disconnected from economic fundamentals and dependent on easy policy by central banks.
While it is positive that central bank policies have reduced tail risks, especially in the euro area, loose fiscal and central bank policies are not a substitute for structural reform, and Cecchetti is sceptical about the effect of further policy easing as debt levels are high and continuing to grow.
“Combining households, non-financial enterprises and government since 2007, global debt has risen a combined $30 trillion dollars, or roughly 40 percent of global GDP, “ Cecchetti told journalists in connection with the publication of BIS’ March quarterly review.
“One reason to be sceptical about the efficacy of further monetary or fiscal easing is that debt levels are very high and continue to rise,” he said, adding: “It is telling that as asset prices are rallying and firms are issuing more debt, investment in the major advanced economies is not picking up.”
Regardless of economic or political persuasion, it is clear that economic growth is driven by investment and this is financed through borrowing, either by governments or the private sector.
But households are overburdened, firms are hoarding cash, and governments have reached their borrowing limits. No one wants to borrow more, nor should they, Cechetti said.
With monetary and fiscal policies reaching their limits, Cecchetti appealed to policy makers to get busy with structural reform, such as addressing the time bomb in the pension and healthcare systems and reducing barriers to the reallocation of capital or workers across sectors.
“Increasing public and private debt ever further until we are not able to fund it is not a substitute for these reforms,” he said.
Large COT Currency Speculators added more to US Dollar bullish positions last week
By CountingPips.com
The latest weekly Commitments of Traders (COT) report, released on Friday by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), showed that large futures traders added to their bullish bets in favor of the US dollar for a fifth consecutive week last week. The bets for American currency continue to be at the highest overall long position since July 17th 2012, according to Reuters research.
Non-commercial large futures traders, including hedge funds and large International Monetary Market speculators, registered an overall US dollar long position of $25.46 billion as of Tuesday March 12th. This was an increase from a total long position of $23.57 billion that was registered on Tuesday March 5th, according to the CFTC’s COT data and trader position calculations by Reuters, which calculates the dollar positions against the euro, British pound, Japanese yen, Australian dollar, Canadian dollar and the Swiss franc.
Individual Currencies Large Speculators Futures Positions:
The individual currency contracts quoted directly against the US dollar last week saw increases for the euro, Australian dollar, New Zealand dollar and the Mexican peso while the British pound sterling, Japanese yen, Canadian dollar and the Swiss franc had a declining number of net contracts compared to the previous week.
Individual Currency Charts:
EuroFX:
EuroFX: Large trader and speculator sentiment for the euro improved slightly last week after declining for four consecutive weeks. Euro contracts edged up to a total net position of -24,787 contracts in the data reported for March 12th following the previous week’s total of -26,116 net contracts on March 5th. This is a change of +1,329 contracts from the previous week.
Euro spec positions, two weeks ago on March 5th, were at their lowest level so far in 2013 and the lowest standing since December 11th 2012 when positions stood at -31,623 contracts before last week’s turnaround. EuroFx speculative contracts have now been in bearish territory for three weeks running.
March 12th 2013 Cot Report Data
Total Open Interest: 213,113
Non-Commerical Large Traders Net Positions: -24,787
Commercial Traders Net Positions: +35,920
Small Traders Net Positions: -11,133
Great Britain Pound:
GBP: British pound sterling spec positions continued to decline last week for an eighth consecutive week and fell to their lowest standing since October 2011. British pound speculative positions decreased to a total of -49,800 net contracts on March 12th following a total of -43,849 net contracts that were reported on March 5th. This was a weekly change of -5,951 large trader contracts.
Pound speculator positions have now been in a bearish position for five straight weeks since crossing over on February 5th and are at the lowest level since October 25th 2011 when positions equaled -50,147 contracts.
March 12th 2013 Cot Report Data
Total Open Interest: 297,130
Non-Commerical Large Traders Net Positions: -49,800
Commercial Traders Net Positions: +82,484
Small Traders Net Positions: -32,684
Japanese Yen:
JPY: Japanese yen speculative contracts decreased sharply last week to decline to the lowest level since December. Japanese yen positions dropped to a total of -93,763 net contracts reported on March 12th following a total of -73,351 net short contracts on March 5th. This is a weekly decrease of -20,412 positions from the prior week.
Yen positions are at their lowest point since December 11th 2012 when short positions equaled -94,401 contracts.
March 12th 2013 Cot Report Data
Total Open Interest: 288,474
Non-Commerical Large Traders Net Positions: -93,763
Commercial Traders Net Positions: +133,865
Small Traders Net Positions: -40,102
Swiss Franc:
CHF: Swiss franc speculator positions continued to descend last week for a fourth consecutive week and are at the lowest level since August 2012. Net positions for the Swiss currency futures dropped to a total of -13,488 contracts on March 12th following a total of -11,450 net contracts reported for March 5th. This is a weekly change of -2,038 from the previous week.
Swiss franc net positions have now been on the short side for four straight weeks and are at the lowest level since August 21st 2012 when positions totaled -15,662 contracts.
March 12th 2013 Cot Report Data
Total Open Interest: 69,408
Non-Commerical Large Traders Net Positions: -13,488
Commercial Traders Net Positions: +26,175
Small Traders Net Positions: -12,687
Canadian Dollar:
CAD: Canadian dollar positions declined lower once again last week to decrease for an eighth consecutive week and to the lowest level since before 2010. Canadian dollar positions fell to a total of -53,397 contracts as of March 12th following a total of -46,663 net contracts that were reported for March 5th. This is a weekly change of -6,734 net contracts following a sharp weekly change of -25,230 the previous week.
March 12th 2013 Cot Report Data
Total Open Interest: 249,150
Non-Commerical Large Traders Net Positions: -53,397
Commercial Traders Net Positions: +67,665
Small Traders Net Positions: -14,268
Australian Dollar:
AUD: The Australian dollar rebounded last week after decreasing for the previous six consecutive weeks. Aussie speculative futures positions rose to a total net amount of +23,266 contracts on March 12th after totaling +7,149 net contracts as of March 5th. This is a weekly change of +16,117 in net positions following the previous week’s -18,546 change.
Australian dollar contracts, on March 5th, were at their lowest level since June 26, 2012 when positions equaled just -2,159 contracts.
March 12th 2013 Cot Report Data
Total Open Interest: 183,095
Non-Commerical Large Traders Net Positions: +23,266
Commercial Traders Net Positions: -23,311
Small Traders Net Positions: +45
New Zealand Dollar:
NZD: New Zealand dollar speculator positions increased slightly last week following declines for two consecutive weeks. NZD contracts rose to a total of +19,350 net long contracts as of March 12th following a total of +19,044 net long contracts on March 5th. This constitutes a weekly change of +306 net contracts to March 12th.
The New Zealand dollar positions have stayed above the +19,000 contracts threshold for ten consecutive weeks.
March 12th 2013 Cot Report Data
Total Open Interest: 32,813
Non-Commerical Large Traders Net Positions: +19,350
Commercial Traders Net Positions: -20,431
Small Traders Net Positions: +1,081
Mexican Peso:
MXN: Mexican peso speculative contracts rebounded last week after falling for seven straight weeks. Peso positions increased to a total of +113,770 net speculative positions as of March 12th following a total of +93,521 contracts that were reported for March 5th. This is a weekly change in net large peso speculator positions of +20,249 contracts.
Peso speculative positions are now back over the +100,000 threshold after falling under this level on March 5th for the first time since November 27th 2012.
March 12th 2013 Cot Report Data
Total Open Interest: 192,764
Non-Commerical Large Traders Net Positions: +113,770
Commercial Traders Net Positions: -122,739
Small Traders Net Positions: +8,969
The Commitment of Traders report is published every Friday by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and shows futures positions data that was reported as of the previous Tuesday (3 days behind).
Each currency contract is a quote for that currency directly against the U.S. dollar, a net short amount of contracts means that more speculators are betting that currency to fall against the dollar and a net long position expect that currency to rise versus the dollar.
(The graphs overlay the forex spot closing price of each Tuesday when COT trader positions are reported for each corresponding spot currency pair.)
See more information and explanation on the weekly COT report from the CFTC website.
Article by CountingPips.com – Forex News & Market Analysis
Is Carl Icahn Banking on Transocean (NYSE: RIG) Becoming an MLP?
By Investment U
In focus today; a nation of deadbeats, Transocean (NYSE: RIG) and the SITFA…
In mid-January the president said, “We are not a nation of deadbeats, we pay our bills.”
According to a recent Wall Street Journal article the numbers tell a very different story.
This current generation of Americans has set records for defaults, not just for the US but in all of recorded history, to the tune of $585 billion. That’s $6000 per household.
And, according to the Journal, there’s a lot more to come.
Household debt today is three times what it was in 1998 and the so called reduction in debt that we have been hearing about on the news has been more bank write offs of bad loans than payment from the folks who owe it.
Households are defaulting on $35 to $40 billion dollars of debt a year, and have been for the past few years.
The Journal said, Americans have walked away from $3 in debt for every $2 paid.
Maybe we aren’t all deadbeats, but there must be a lot of them out there.
Can you imagine how bad the financial collapse would have been if everyone, banks included, had their feet held to the fire?
Either money really does grow on trees in Washington, or someone will eventually have to pay the bills. A bill so big it is almost unbelievable.
Will Transocean Become an MLP in 2014?
Transocean is making big strides since the Gulf oil disaster and has attracted some very big attention.
Carl Ichan, the billionaire and activist investor stated he intends to own 3.5% of the company. That would make him the third largest stock holder behind two mega institutions.
A MarketWatch article stated that Ichan might be in line for a big cash distribution if RIG shifts its structure to an MLP. Analysts give it no chance of happening this year but it appears to be in the cards.
RIG’s earnings beat analyst’s expectation in the recent quarter and since the announcement, Ichan has been screaming for a $4 per share dividend from the $6 billion in cash the company has on its books.
According to Barron’s, drillers like RIG show better share prices in an MLP structure than in a traditional corporate set up. And, better yet, most of the tax burden in an MLP would be tax deferred. MLP’s do not pay corporate taxes.
Barrons says compared to its biggest rival, Schlumberger, RIG is cheap trading at just nine times 2014 earnings while Schlumberger is sitting at about 13 times. And RIG only has to hit its mid-2014 estimates to show earnings growth of 27%.
Numbers like these and the fact that as the yield battle with Ichan develops will see another pop in the stock.
The shares are currently trading at $52 to $53 a share, but hit a high of $161 in 2008 and were at about $85 just before the Gulf disaster.
Take a look at RIG, and there’s an report below that is worth reading. Just click on the link.
[Editor’s Note: We’ve also uncovered a technology company that is likely to shift toward REIT status in the next two years. In the meantime its actually hiding its immense cash flow for tax purposes. But this should prove to be a huge catalyst for the stock. For the full story, click here.]
Slap in the Face Award: Crooked Banker Edition
This week the sitfa goes to the Attorney General, Eric Holder and an Iowa Senator, Charles Grassley.
During a recent Senate hearing Senator Grassley asked the AG why no banker has ever been prosecuted by the DOJ for their role in the financial collapse.
The question was fielded by an Assistant AG and his answer might be one of the most outrageous you’ll ever hear.
This is incredible; the Assistant AG said the DOJ consults experts on the subject to determine if a prosecution would hurt the economy. He admitted that the decision to prosecute is not a function of law, it is dependent on the economic impact it has on the country and the world economy.
That’s insane enough, but Grassley’s response was even better.
Grassley essentially said he understood and agreed, but he’s concerned.
Concerned!
Trillions of dollars disappeared and he’s concerned.
I should have been a banker.
Good Investing,
Steve
Article By Investment U
Original Article: Is Carl Icahn Banking on Transocean (NYSE: RIG) Becoming an MLP?
Monetary Policy Week in Review – Mar 16, 2013: Eleven central banks keep rates steady, Norway delays rate rise
COUNTRY | MSCI | NEW RATE | OLD RATE | 1 YEAR AGO |
MAURITIUS | 4.90% | 4.90% | 4.90% | |
MOZAMBIQUE | 9.50% | 9.50% | 13.75% | |
KENYA | FM | 9.50% | 9.50% | 18.00% |
SERBIA | FM | 11.75% | 11.75% | 9.50% |
NEW ZEALAND | DM | 2.50% | 2.50% | 2.50% |
SOUTH KOREA | EM | 2.75% | 2.75% | 3.25% |
PHILIPPINES | EM | 3.50% | 3.50% | 4.00% |
SWITZERLAND | DM | 0.25% | 0.25% | 0.25% |
LATVIA | 2.50% | 2.50% | 3.50% | |
NORWAY | DM | 1.50% | 1.50% | 1.50% |
RUSSIA | EM | 8.25% | 8.25% | 8.00% |
COUNTRY | MSCI | MEETING | RATE | 1 YEAR AGO |
INDIA | EM | 19-Mar | 7.75% | 8.50% |
NIGERIA | FM | 19-Mar | 12.00% | 12.00% |
UNITED STATES | DM | 20-Mar | 0.25% | 0.25% |
SOUTH AFRICA | EM | 20-Mar | 5.00% | 5.50% |
ICELAND | 20-Mar | 6.00% | 5.00% | |
EGYPT | EM | 21-Mar | 9.25% | 9.25% |
CHILE | EM | 21-Mar | 5.00% | 5.00% |
TRINIDAD & TOBAGO | 22-Mar | 2.75% | 3.00% |
Kris Sayce’s Money Weekend Digest: 16 March 2013
Energy: Dance Dance Revolution
This one’s a little left field compared to how we usually cover energy stories. Nonetheless it makes a fascinating case for alternative ways of creating energy.
First, let’s get a basic understanding of Piezoelectricity. If you’re wondering what the heck that is, in short, it’s the energy created by stress applied to certain solid materials…it’s electricity from pressure (vibrations).
But if we (Sam) may now digress ever so slightly. The Dutch love a good nightclub (can vouch for this as our family heritage is Dutch). And what does one do when typically at a nightclub? Dance.
Believe it or not, some creative Dutch designers from Studio Roosegaarde have pieced together dancing at a nightclub and piezoelectricity! They call it the sustainable dance floor.
The idea behind it is the dance floor vibrates from the dancing, which in turn creates energy to power the lighting and stage equipment. We think harnessing the power of ‘the boogie’ and the ‘Gangnam Style’ would be the best ways to really get the power pumping.
What this really means though is that everywhere we move we create vibrations and energy. Vibrations and energy when harnessed in the right way can lead to a vast array of power gains and efficiencies. This type of experimental work also shows us that there are people from all different aspects of industry looking at ways of solving some of the world’s big problems.
Maybe the future isn’t about just one way of solving our energy and power problems. But hundreds if not thousands of different ways being used together to be more sustainable and energy efficient.
Gold: Will Gold or Shares Do Best in 2013?
What has gold done since we wrote to you in last week’s Money Weekend? Er, not much.
And quite frankly we’re not convinced it will do much in the near future. Whether that’s days, weeks or months we can’t say. But what we can say is that it’s surely testing the patience of ‘fair weather’ gold investors, i.e. those investors who only bought gold because they expected to make quick gains.
The fate of the gold price has even sparked some discussion around the office. As you’ve probably read over the past couple of weeks, your editor is concerned that gold is behaving just like any other electronically traded asset.
What we mean by that is the vast majority of people who buy and sell the gold exchange traded funds (ETF’s) have no interest in ever taking physical delivery of the gold that underlies the ETF.
Heck, most of them probably aren’t even sound money advocates. Just in the same way that many investors buy and sell shares without really caring about what the company does.
But my old pal, Greg Canavan (editor of Sound Money.Sound Investments) isn’t so sure. He says there are still plenty of people buying gold for wealth preservation…a kind of insurance. In his latest weekly update he showed two charts comparing the performance of the US S&P 500 and the gold price. We’ve reproduced them below:
S&P 500
US Dollar Gold Price
Greg says about these charts:
‘The world’s largest stock market index has gone nowhere over the past 13 years. And everyone’s talking about a new bull market?‘In contrast…[the 20 year chart of gold]…looks much more like a bull market (in progress) to me. Yet the perception is that the gold bull market is over and a new one is beginning in equities. That’s market logic and crowd think for you!’
We like Greg’s point. But we also think that markets behave irrationally at times (some would argue they’re always irrational). It’s for that reason we believe stocks will do better than gold this year, next year, and possibly into 2015.
Of course, we could be wrong. And we’re not about to sell any of our gold in order to buy stocks. But we are using new cash flows in order to increase our share exposure – something we’ve advised investors do for more than a year.
That said, we’re keeping a close eye on the market for signs of a sell-off. Our in-house technical trader, Murray Dawes, says the market is approaching a key technical level right now that could have a big impact on the market’s direction for the rest of this year.
Technology: Science, Technology and Innovation at 345kph
We thought that as we hear the sound of 22, 2.4 Litre V8′s humming around near the office at an astonishing 18,000RPM we should give credit to the technical innovation that Formula OneTM (F1) has given us over the years.
Ron Dennis, Executive Chairman of the McLaren Group sums it up well:
‘Intrinsically, at its heart, it (Formula OneTM) is about technology and scientific innovation carried out under the extreme of time pressures, with a relentless fortnightly assessment of progress and performance.’
No matter where you look it’s pretty hard to find industry that brings together aerodynamicists, quantum mechanics, computer scientists, engineers, fluid dynamicists, fabricators, sports scientists and race car drivers.
So it’s no surprise that in an environment like this (‘an Intersection’ as Frans Johansson describes in The Medici Effect) innovative and cutting edge technologies are born.
To outline a couple of the F1 breakthroughs you may have heard of:
- Carbon fibre. In its early days companies such as Rolls-Royce used carbon fibre to create parts and components for their engines. But the first carbon fibre monocoque (structural skin) was raced in 1981 by John Watson in the McLaren MP4/1. This was the first time a monocoque had been constructed from carbon fibre. To see the level of safety this gave drivers, have a look at John’s demonstration at Monza. Because of F1′s advances in the use of carbon fibre we now find it in everyday items like cars, bikes, prosthetics, planes, golf clubs and furniture.
- ‘Green’ Technologies. Surprisingly to some, more recent breakthroughs have been in engine and fuel efficiency. Next year the 2014 season will require all F1 engines be 1.6 litre (less capacity than a Toyota Corolla) V6′s. This is a far cry from 3 litre V10′s in 2005. Not only that, but the Federation Internationale de l’Automobile (FIA) has said along with the Kinetic Energy Recovery Systems (introduced in 2008) teams may now use pioneering Heat Energy Recovery Systems. These together will be a major factor in how the engine produces its total power. Without these ‘green’ systems, team effectively are running with their feet tied together.
So next time someone brings up the subject of how horrible F1 is for the world (these conversations usually pop up around Melbourne Grand Prix time) use those two simple examples. You might find yourself in the midst of a healthy debate on the benefit that F1 technology brings to us.
Further to this if you happen to switch over the TV to watch the race on the weekend, or are trackside enjoying it all first hand, have a look at the pit lane activity. Like a swarm of bees, all those scientist and engineers buzzing about are the true innovators of some of the modern technologies we often take for granted.
Health: Why Something So Bad Could Be Something So Good
There’s no doubt that cigarettes are bad for your health. Even pack a day smokers should agree on that. So what if we told you that there’s actually something good about a cigarette? (We aren’t condoning smoking cigarettes, and neither does the rest of this article provide sufficient reason to keep puffing away, or start. We hope you get that distinction.)
Over the last few years a number of studies (‘Smoking, nicotine and Parkinson’s disease’, by Maryka Quick at the Parkinson’s Institute is one example) have repeatedly found that smoking over a period of time significantly lowers the risk of developing Parkinson’s disease (PD). Compared with those who have never smoked, or smoked for shorter periods of time, the results are conclusive.
So is there something in a cigarette that provides the answer to slowing down, or even reducing the effect of PD in those diagnosed?
Scientists don’t know the answer to that yet. But thanks to the Michael J. Fox Foundation (MJFF), researchers at The Philipps University and University of Rochester Medical Center are having a really good crack at finding out. The suspicion is nicotine is the key to the PD problem. So with the backing of the MJFF a new clinical trial has been set up in the US and Germany. You can check out the podcast about it here.
What the trial is planning to do is test the impact of a simple nicotine patch on those in the early stages of PD. We won’t know the results of the trial for 12 months, but seeing as there is no current drug to hinder or decrease the impact of PD this is one to keep an eye on.
Mining: Welcome the New Breed of Tech Entrepreneurs
[Ed note: The following is adapted from the latest weekly update sent to Australian Small-Cap Investigator subscribers.]
Today we find ourselves at the beginning of another Space Race. But this time round it’s not governments, it’s private industry. It’s the commercialisation of space.
The real financial opportunities they see are chasing the abundance of resources and mineral deposits contained in the asteroids flying around the planet.
To give you an idea of exactly how big a resource is out there, in 1997 there were 33,000 known asteroids orbiting the sun within reach of earth. Today it’s over 610,000, as astronomers find more of these flying rocks.
Why does this matter? For a start, the team from Planetary Resources, where John S. Lewis, Professor of Planetary Science at the University of Arizona, has been consulting, claim one asteroid (only a few hundred metres wide) could contain more than 1.5 times the known world-reserves of the platinum group of metals.
Still it’s seen as the realms of science fiction. Some doubters say it’s crazy to think we could mine an asteroid for its resources. The doubters don’t see an economically viable reason to do it at all and they say the cost outweighs the benefit.
For instance, if a solid gold asteroid the size of the Melbourne Cricket Ground passed by the earth, even the possibility of someone ‘mining’ this gold would have a drastic impact on the gold price. This could make the prospect of mining the Asteroid’s gold a marginal business and therefore not worthwhile.
Now, this may still sound a bit ‘Star Trek’, but history confirms the speed with which crazy ideas become reality. The dedication is there and there are a number of competing firms. They all want to be the first to make space a commercial reality.
And it’s not just space. The idea of deep-sea mining is starting to gain traction too, and will probably happen before ‘asteroid mining’.
But anyway, what this means is you can expect the new Space Race to move just as quickly as the last. In the years ahead you’ll likely see space tourism lead to hotels in space (one company is already working on this) and from mining asteroids to mining and populating Mars.
Sound crazy? Maybe. But as we said above, sometimes the craziest ideas become the most successful.
Kris Sayce and Sam Volkering
From the Archives…
Why the Stock Market Boom is on Pause
8-03-2013 – Kris Sayce
Why the Dow Jones Record High Doesn’t Matter
7-03-2013 – Murray Dawes
Taking China’s Economic Pulse from Hong Kong
6-03-2013 – Dr Alex Cowie
Buy Gold When They’re Crying…Sell Gold When They’re Yelling
5-03-2013 – Dr Alex Cowie
Do You Want to Be Right About Investing, or Do You Want to Make Money?
4-03-2013 – Kris Sayce
Index funds are parasites and are going to kill the market
Source: Stockopedia – Stock Market Research Network.
Everywhere you go these days you hear yet another investor singing the virtues of investing in low cost index trackers. Frankly the sales pitch makes sense doesn’t it? It’s very easy to understand and goes something like this:
“The majority of active fund managers underperform the market averages so why should you pay 2% for the privilege? If you buy an index fund you can guarantee average performance and thus beat the average fund manager.”
It seems that this idea is winning. The mainstream press sings the praises of low cost passive investing, while the knives are out for active fat cat fund managers. Meanwhile a Tsunami of money in the fund management industry is flowing into passive vehicles, and the flow of funds into the big providers like Vanguard is quite astonishing. The advisory community is voting with its feet and has decided that index investing is the light.
But my nostrils have started flaring from a growing stench of groupthink and I can’t help thinking that somehow this is all going to end in tears.
The ultimate piggyback ride
In a way, index investing is the ultimate piggyback ride on the coattails of the active management community. If you think about it, the selection of stocks that are included within the major indices is solely due to the discerning opinion of the active management community. These professionals bid the price of a stock up until it becomes a candidate for promotion to the relevant major index – such as the FTSE100 or Samp;P500. At this point index funds jump on the bandwagon and buy. The idea that this is a ‘passive’ process is beyond me – it’s an active decision to ride on the coattails of other people’s decision making.
The irony is that index funds haven’t had to pay the salaries of the people who pick their stocks for them. Index investing has been monstrously successful partly due to the fact that through this trick they’ve kept the costs of management extremely low. If there were any justice index funds would pay a tax to the active management community for their service.
But piggybacking can only be a successful strategy if you don’t get too heavy for your ride. As index investors have started to dominate the stock markets they have started to create some terrible unintended consequences. The horse’s knees are starting to buckle.
When success breeds failure
There was an excellent paper written in 2010 by Professor Jeffrey Wurgler of NYU Stern School of Business that I highly recommend reading. He preaches that the stock market has only a finite capacity to absorb passive investment funds without materially and detrimentally impacting the market.
The wall of money investing in passive trackers is causing prices to detach from reality – inclusion in the Samp;P500 index causes a 9% jump on average in the stocks price – but it doesn’t stop there. There is evidence that Samp;P 500 membership creates a price premium of 40% over non members. Many commentators, including the excellent blog at Psyfitec have warned of a looming ‘index bubble’, while Morck and Yang suggest that investing in these indices is essentially a “large cap growth and momentum strategy that can’t last forever – this “index bubble” will pop“.
But there’s more, he suggests the whole market structure is creaking. When a stock is added to an index it’s price action detaches from the rest of the market and it “begins to move more closely with its new 499 neighbours. It is as if it has joined a new school of fish”. This accentuates gross price distortions and means that real valuations are less likely to be realised.
The delicious irony is that this creates an environment where large cap active fund managers can no longer harvest their expected returns from value situations. We’ve seen many great investors, even legends like Bill Miller, lose their way in recent years. Could it be that passive investors are slowly killing the hand that fed them in the first place? That active investors actually underperform due to the growing load on their back? I can’t help but hear the echo of Aesop’s fables in this story – that index investors are killing the goose that laid their golden egg.
Don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater
Everybody should read John Bogle’s classic “The Little Book of Common Sense Investing“. His teachings on the ‘relentless rules of humble arithmetic‘ and minimising costs are priceless. Passive investing has huge merits but there are perhaps better ways to do it than investing in the big market cap weighted index trackers.
In this respect, Joel Greenblatt’s latest book, “The big secret for the small investor” is a great eye-opener. It preaches that many would be better off investing in equally weighted or fundamentally weighted funds. But even better than this is to build your own portfolio around solid and sound investment principles. Greenblatt preaches a mantra that we at Stockopedia stand by, that you can beat these index funds by creating your own low cost systematic investment strategy and investing directly in the underlying shares. We are building the tools to do this and believe fundamentally that it’s a saner approach than the growing index groupthink in much of the institutional money management world.
Further reading:
- FT Alphaville – “Did noone ever consider that index investing was dangerous“
- Psyfitec – “Hubble Bubble Index Trouble“
- Canadian Financial DIY – “Index investing victim of its own success“
Original Article: Index funds are parasites and are going to kill the market