Miners are in for a hard time.
China has been an accident waiting to happen ever since the financial crisis blew up.
You can’t base your country’s entire business model on exporting cheap goods and then expect to keep prospering when the rest of the global economy is falling off a cliff.
So what China did was to pile even more money and resources into expanding its infrastructure. But rising inflation, shoddily-built projects, and soaring property prices saw the government crackdown on credit availability.
Now it seems clear that China is having the hard landing that the bulls always said was impossible.
And a hard landing for China spells disaster for the mining sector…
The Trouble With Mining
We’ve been bearish on China for quite some time. As a natural result, we’ve been bearish on mining stocks too. China is the biggest driver of commodity demand. If China’s economy slows, commodity demand drops, and so do prices. If commodity prices fall, miners run into trouble.
That’s how it’s played out so far.
There’s probably more to come. The problem with mining is that it’s a cyclical business. It’s as boom and bust as they come. The trouble is that mining projects take so long to develop, whereas commodity prices move pretty quickly.
At the bottom of a commodity cycle, when prices are low, no one is investing in new capacity. Miners are barely making money as it is. So when prices rise, there’s no rush to open new mines.
As prices continue to rise, interest picks up. Some projects that were uneconomic, become viable. But supply still tends to lag behind demand, because no one wants to commit to making big investments while they’re still not sure that demand will continue.
Eventually of course, prices get a lot higher, everyone decides that the demand will be never-ending, and you get a lot of investment in projects that are only viable at high prices.
At that point, any drop-off in prices becomes a real problem. Because miners are still geared up to expand, based on commodity prices being at stratospheric levels. So you end up with revenues being unable to cover costs.
It looks as though we’re at this point in the cycle. The bulls are increasingly being forced to stake their hopes for the sector on a fresh bout of ‘stimulus’ from China, or on a Chinese consumption boom, which would boost certain metals at the expense of others.
But from where I sit, it’s pretty clear that this particular supercycle is over. It doesn’t mean the global economy is going to collapse, or that China will never build another road or city again. But the best times for the mining sector, for this business cycle, are over.
Why Asset Allocation Matters
That’s why I see no compelling reason to hold most mining stocks. We’ve always said that one of the most important parts of your investment strategy is your asset allocation. You make money by being in the parts of the market that are going up, and avoiding the ones that are going down.
Rather than spend your time looking for the best stocks in sectors that are in a downtrend, you’d be better off hunting for a mix of stocks in sectors that are in an uptrend. So with fundamental conditions for miners clearly deteriorating fast, the best bet for most investors is just to avoid or get out of the sector altogether.
The one area in the industrial sector I’d perhaps exclude is the mining of coal used in power generation. Getting the right energy mix in the years to come is going to be tough, and we may find we’re more reliant on coal than we’d like.
But beyond that, there is one area of mining I’d definitely say you should keep in your portfolio: that’s gold miners. Gold miners have had a pretty miserable time for the past few years. But unlike industrial metals miners, demand for their product – gold – isn’t collapsing. In fact, gold miners could benefit from the rest of the industry’s woes.
Why? A key problem for all miners has been input costs. The same demand that pushed up commodity prices also drove up raw material costs for miners. On top of that, demand for mining equipment, and skilled staff, drove up wage and machinery costs too.
But as projects get delayed or cancelled, that’ll all change. As the FT reported earlier this week, “one sliver of positive news from the miners was that rampant cost inflation, which has eaten into earnings and pushed up the cost of big development projects, seems to be abating.”
Anglo American, for example, “expects costs to rise by about 2% in the second half of [2012] – down from 4% in the first half, and 8% in 2011″.
That’s got to be good news for gold miners. If cost pressures ease up, but the price of gold stays strong or rises further, that should lead to higher profit margins.
John Stepek
Contributing Editor, Money Morning
Publisher’s Note: This article originally appeared in MoneyWeek (UK)
Publisher’s Note: This is an edited version of an article that originally appeared in MoneyWeek (UK)
From the Archives…
Read This Gold Price Warning Before You Buy Another Stock
24-08-2012 – Kris Sayce
Stocks Are Up – Is it a Good Time to Buy?
23-08-2012 – Kris Sayce
It’s About Freedom of Speech: What if We Couldn’t Write to You Anymore?
22-08-2012 – Kris Sayce
Things Are Looking Up for Gold
21-08-2012 – Bengt Saelensminde
The Good News About Europe’s Missing Pre-nup
20-08-2012 – Nick Hubble
